‘The Green Knight’ Adopts a Medieval Approach to ‘Modern’ Problems

Toward the beginning of the new film The Green Knight, King Arthur turns to Gawain, his young nephew and (later) one of the most famous Knights of the Round Table, and asks him to tell a story. Ashamed, Gawain (played by Dev Patel) tells Arthur (Sean Harris) that he has no stories to tell. Arthur’s wife, Queen Guinevere (Kate Dickie), smiles and says, “Yet.” Viewers immediately know that adventure awaits—a feeling confirmed soon after, when the mysterious Green Knight appears at the court’s Christmas celebrations. Gawain accepts the Green Knight’s challenge of a “Christmas game,” setting the stage for a saga filled with magic, horror and—ultimately—honor.

Written, directed and produced by filmmaker David Lowery, the movie is based on a 14th-century Middle English poem titled Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. Some of the details between the film and its source material are, of course, different, but the themes at their respective hearts remain consistent. In both, Gawain launches on a journey that is as much about self-discovery and contemplation as it is about an epic, heroic quest to vanquish a magical foe. In fact, much of the poem is about how Gawain is readying to face his doom, waiting for the Green Knight to repay the blow that Gawain struck the Christmas before.

The Green Knight | Official Trailer HD | A24

Watch on

Although the poem only exists in one manuscript copy, it’s been celebrated in both popular and academic culture for the past several centuries. Richard Godden, a literary scholar at Louisiana State University, explains how the medieval poem subverts readers’ expectations: People tend to think that “medieval literature didn’t have a sense of subjectivity and self-consciousness,” that people living in the European Middle Ages didn’t think about themselves and their place in the world. But that’s just not true. Sir Gawain and the Green Knight “is a kind of coming-of-age story,” says Godden. It’s all about Gawain becoming a man, about Gawain becoming “Gawain.” In the film, rendering Gawain as younger, as yet unaccomplished, and not really even a knight, a man who over the course of the movie has to confront difficult situations on his own, makes the medieval theme of “becoming”—of growing up—all the starker.

The original 14th-century source is set in what one can think of as the “Arthurverse,” a broad and loosely connected collection of stories centered on Arthur and produced over the course of several hundred years. Unlike modern franchise universes, no one had authority over the stories of King Arthur and his court; rather, Camelot was just a convenient setting with familiar characters whom medieval writers could feature in any kind of story they wanted to. Gawain shows up in many of these tales, usually as one of Arthur’s most heroic, perfect knights.

Not so in the film. We first meet Gawain in a brothel, where he begs his lover to stay in bed rather than go to Christmas mass. We learn that he’s Arthur’s nephew, the son of the king’s sister (played by Sarita Choudhury), whose witchcraft—perhaps in cahoots with Arthur—sparks the drama. At the Christmas feast, a Green Knight, a massive creature of wood and moss, strides into the hall and challenges the knights to trade blows with him. His opponent will strike their blow now, while the Green Knight will take his at the Green Chapel on Christmas one year later. Gawain lops off the knight’s head. But the towering figures picks his head right back up and rides off after uttering the ominous warning “One year hence.”

Afraid and unsure after a stressful year of waiting, Gawain rides out to meet his fate. What follows is a strange, episodic journey: being robbed, recovering the head of a decapitated saint, speaking to giants, meeting a mystical fox, freezing in intense cold, staying with an odd group of nobles who seem to know more than they say. Throughout the quest, viewers watch Gawain ask overarching questions about what it means to become an adult, as well as more specific queries like what to do when you want to have sex with the wrong person.

These perhaps appear to be very modern concerns, a long way from the stereotypical medieval Europe of the “Dark Ages” that only thought in blunt categories, that, in the words of Swiss historian Jakob Burckhardt, “lay dreaming or half awake beneath a common veil … woven of faith, illusion, and childish prepossession, through which the world and history were seen clad in strange hues.” But the film’s very weirdness, along with its familiarity, can be seen within the medieval text itself—a tale that is strange and episodic, alternating wildly between humor and horror, embracing contradictions rather than trying to resolve them.

Anna Wilson, an expert on medieval literature at Harvard University, says that it’s difficult to really appreciate the poem by itself. Though it’s “incredibly beautiful, complex, weird and rich,” it wasn’t designed to be enjoyed alone, but rather as part of the broader Arthurverse. Wilson adds that “medieval readers or listeners would be approaching [the poem] with the expectation, ‘What is this poem going to [have to] do with Gawain and with the genre of Arthurian knight quest romance?’ both of which they’d already know very well. ... Gawain is constantly navigating interactions with people who have heard stories about him and are judging him against them. He gets asked whether he’s the real Gawain, [and] he’s trying to measure up to multiple different versions of Gawain.” A final challenge with a noble lord and lady, each of whom want something from Gawain, creates an irresolvable conflict. Gawain all but breaks down when he hears the haunting words uttered by the lady as she, almost with disgust, gives him a belt that will supposedly protect him from the Green Knight: “You are no knight.”

And that’s the point. Patel’s version of Gawain is not perfect in any way, but he grows across the course of the film as he experiences adventures previously found only in stories. He clearly lives in a world in which tales about him have spread across the island and echoed across hill and dale, making it hard for the actual man to figure out his way amid the din of myth. He lives not only in the shadow of his uncle, King Arthur, but his own—one made across many retellings of this very tale. At the end of the poem, Gawain pledges to wear the belt from that day forward as a mark of his many failures (and the lessons he learned) during his quest. This tension of sin, regret and potential redemption may feel very modern, but it isn’t. The belt and what it represents instead stretch across the centuries and remind contemporary observers that people in the past were just as messy, complex and thoughtful as we are today.

David M. Perry | | READ MORE

David M. Perry is the co-author of Oathbreakers: The War of Brothers That Shattered an Empire and Made Medieval Europe. He's currently the senior academic advisor in the History Department at the University of Minnesota - Twin Cities.

Matthew Gabriele | | READ MORE

Matthew Gabriele is a professor of medieval studies and chair of the Department of Religion & Culture at Virginia Tech. His latest book, co-authored with David M. Perry, is Oathbreakers: The War of Brothers That Shattered an Empire and Made Medieval Europe. See more at profgabriele.com.